ABAP SICF服务和Java Servlet的比较

In my opinion ABAP ICF handler and Java Servlet play the same role in enhancement which enables your web server with additional functionality.

This blog will not introduce how an ICF handler class in ABAP or a Servlet in Java are developed, but focus the way those instances of handler class or Servlet are spawned by Web Server.

Let’s first study the Servlet spawn behavior in Java.

Servlet in Java

According to Servlet specification, http request against a given url will be served by the same single instance of servlet.

For example, I have developed a simple Servlet which just returns “Hello world” as response. I map it with url starting with “/Hello”.

In the doGet method, I print out the current thread id and instance address to try to verify if every request is served with the SAME servlet instance.

System.out.println("User id: " + userId + " at thread: " + Thread.currentThread().getId() + " current instance: " + this);

In client side I use jQuery to send out five different request simultaneously:

var LOCAL = "http://localhost:9098/JerryServlet/Hello?userId=";
var PREFIX = "i04241";
function main() {
 for( var i = 0; i < 5; i++) {
 var url = LOCAL + PREFIX + i;
 var html = getPostByAJAX(url);
 console.log("response: " + html);
 }
}
$(function(){
	main();
});
function getPostByAJAX(requestURL){
 var html = $.ajax({
 	url: requestURL, async: true}).responseText;
 return html;
}

When executing the client JavaScript code, I observe in Server console and could find out that these five requests are handled by the same Servlet instance ,however in different threads.

Since I perform the request in an asynchronous mode, so the response of those five requests are processed and returned in parallel.

How singleton behavior of Servlet is achieved

The instance of requested Servlet will only be initialized when it is asked for the first time. The below two-fold instance checking against null is a typical thread-safe implementation pattern for Singleton in Java.

The method loadServlet in class StandardWrapper will call constructor of my sample Servlet via reflection. All subsequent request will be served by this singleton.

Thread pool in Java Servlet

This thread pool behavior is easy to observe, just set breakpoint in doGet method in my Servlet, line 58:

Perform the client code to send five requests, then in Eclipse we can see the five working threads stopped at the breakpoint at the same time:

From the bottom of callstack we get the hint that those working threads are centrally managed by the Thread pool.

ICF Handler class in ABAP

Create a simple ICF service in tcode SICF and implement its handler class.

Set a breakpoint on method HANDLE_REQUEST, then trigger the request sending in client code:

Five debugger windows will pop up for the same time, each for one separate ABAP session where the request is handled.

From this source code we know the fact that in ABAP, the instance of handler class does not behave as singleton in Java Servlet.

From debugging we can observe that different session has different ICF handler instance which are isolated among each other.

Further reading

I have written a series of blogs which compare the language feature among ABAP, JavaScript and Java. You can find a list of them below:

• Lazy Loading, Singleton and Bridge design pattern in JavaScript and in ABAP
• Functional programming – Simulate Curry in ABAP
• Functional Programming – Try Reduce in JavaScript and in ABAP
• Simulate Mockito in ABAP
• A simulation of Java Spring dependency injection annotation @Inject in ABAP
• Singleton bypass – ABAP and Java
• Weak reference in ABAP and Java
• Fibonacci Sequence in ES5, ES6 and ABAP
• Java byte code and ABAP Load
• How to write a correct program rejected by compiler: Exception handling in Java and in ABAP
• An small example to learn Garbage collection in Java and in ABAP
• String Template in ABAP, ES6, Angular and React
• Try to access static private attribute via ABAP RTTI and Java Reflection
• Local class in ABAP, Java and JavaScript
• Integer in ABAP, Java and JavaScript
• Covariance in Java and simulation in ABAP
• Various Proxy Design Pattern implementation variants in Java and ABAP
• Tag(Marker) Interface in ABAP and Java
• Bitwise operation ( OR, AND, XOR ) on ABAP Integer
• ABAP ICF handler and Java Servlet
• ADBC and JDBC
• CL_ABAP_CORRESPONDING, CL_JAVA_CORRESPONDING and CL_JS_CORRESPONDING
• Build an Cross Site Scripting example in Java and ABAP
• Play around with JSONP in nodeJS server and ABAP server

要获取更多Jerry的原创文章，请关注公众号"汪子熙":