What are the differences between an LES-SGS model and a RANS based turbulence model?
The biggest difference between LES and RANS is that, contrary to LES, RANS assumes that \(\overline{u'_i} = 0\) (see the Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes equations). In LES the filter is spatially based and acts to reduce the amplitude of the scales of motion, whereas in RANS the time filter removes ALL scales of motion with timescales less than the filter width.
I would recommend reading Fröhlich, Jochen, and Dominic von Terzi. "Hybrid LES/RANS methods for the simulation of turbulent flows." Progress in Aerospace Sciences 44.5 (2008): 349-377.
From that paper, specifically the section 'Structural similarity of LES and RANS equations', you can see that the equations being solved are essentially the same for LES and RANS, however, the physics are different. The main difference being that in RANS the unclosed term is a function of the turbulent kinetic energy and the turbulent dissipation rate whereas in LES the closure term is dependent on the length scale of the numerical grid. So in RANS the results are independent of the grid resolution!
A model qualifies as an LES model if it explicitly involves in one or
the other way the step size of the computational grid. RANS models, in
contrast, only depend on physical quantities, including geometric
features like the wall distance.
As far as typical processes, this figure summarizes it pretty well. DNS resolves all scales of motion, all the way down to the Kolmogorov scale. LES is next up and resolves most of the scales, with the smallest eddies being modeled. RANS is on the other end of the spectrum from DNS, where only the large-scale eddies are resolved and the remaining scales are modeled.
The figure above is from André Bakker's lectures: http://www.bakker.org/dartmouth06/engs150/10-rans.pdf
DNS: Very small scale flow (ex:turbulent boundary layers). Currently computationally intractable for most problems.
LES: Aims to solve the computational cost that DNS poses and reveals the eddies hidden behind the mean in RANS. Good for coastal scale scale 2D simulations and possibly lab-scale 3D simulations with a highly optimized parallel code.
RANS: It is the least computationally expensive method that is used for turbulent modeling, but it is really not very good when certain phenomena cannot be averaged, such as instabilities. Acoustic waves are also incorrectly modeled because they are inherently unsteady processes which can't be averaged, so typically modelers will crank up the turbulent and numerical viscosity to remove acoustic waves from the system.
This shows the main difference between LES and RANS.
What are the differences between an LES-SGS model and a RANS based turbulence model?的更多相关文章
- stall and flow separation on airfoil or blade
stall stall and flow separation Table of Contents 1. Stall and flow separation 1.1. Separation of Bo ...
- Core - Provide an easy way to store administrator and user model differences in a custom store (e.g., in a database)
https://www.devexpress.com/Support/Center/Question/Details/S32444/core-provide-an-easy-way-to-store- ...
- [翻译+山寨]Hangfire Highlighter Tutorial
前言 Hangfire是一个开源且商业免费使用的工具函数库.可以让你非常容易地在ASP.NET应用(也可以不在ASP.NET应用)中执行多种类型的后台任务,而无需自行定制开发和管理基于Windows ...
- EF 5 最佳实践白皮书
Performance Considerations for Entity Framework 5 By David Obando, Eric Dettinger and others Publish ...
- (转)LSTM NEURAL NETWORK FOR TIME SERIES PREDICTION
LSTM NEURAL NETWORK FOR TIME SERIES PREDICTION Wed 21st Dec 2016 Neural Networks these days are th ...
- 转:python获取linux系统及性能信息
原文:http://amitsaha.github.io/site/notes/articles/python_linux/article.html In this article, we will ...
- (转)分布式深度学习系统构建 简介 Distributed Deep Learning
HOME ABOUT CONTACT SUBSCRIBE VIA RSS DEEP LEARNING FOR ENTERPRISE Distributed Deep Learning, Part ...
- 【ASP.NET MVC 5】第27章 Web API与单页应用程序
注:<精通ASP.NET MVC 3框架>受到了出版社和广大读者的充分肯定,这让本人深感欣慰.目前该书的第4版不日即将出版,现在又已开始第5版的翻译,这里先贴出该书的最后一章译稿,仅供大家 ...
- Why Apache Beam? A data Artisans perspective
https://cloud.google.com/dataflow/blog/dataflow-beam-and-spark-comparison https://github.com/apache/ ...
随机推荐
- db2数据库表操作错误SQL0668N Operation not allowed for reason code "1" on table "表". SQLSTATE=57016的解决方法
错误sql Operation not allowed for reason code "1" on table "MARKET.PURE_USER".. SQ ...
- 解决IDEA输入法输入中文候选框不显示问题(亲测谷歌拼音完美解决问题)
解决方法:关掉idea,进入idea的安装目录找到jre64文件夹重命名为jre642(随便什么名字都行)如下图 然后找到jdk安装目录下的jre文件复制到上图idea的安装目录下并改名为jre64 ...
- 用Vue来实现音乐播放器(十六):滚动列表的实现
滚动列表是一个基础组件 他是基于scroll组件实现的 在base文件夹下面创建一个list-view文件夹 里面有list-view.vue组件 <template> < ...
- Linux随笔 - vi/vim 编辑器显示行号
显示行号 1. 打开vi 编辑器 2. 输入 :set number 3. 回车 关闭行号显示 1. 打开vi 编辑器 2. 输入 :set nonumber 3. 回车 行号在每次打开 vi/v ...
- flutter dialog异常Another exception was thrown: No MaterialLocalizations found
flutter dialog异常Another exception was thrown: No MaterialLocalizations found import 'package:flutter ...
- spring map获取同类型的bean
今天看博客怎么减少if else 方法, 才发现spring 还有很多功能我没有用到,以后真的得花时间学学spring,今天学到的东西如下: 1.定义一个接口 store public interfa ...
- Python笔记(二十二)_魔法方法_基本魔法方法
__init__(self[,...]) __init__和__new__组成python的构造器,但__init__更多的是负责初始化操作,相当于一个项目中的配置文件,__new__才是真正的构造函 ...
- 20190909 SpringBoot集成Swagger
SpringBoot集成Swagger 1. 引入依赖 // SpringBoot compile('org.springframework.boot:spring-boot-starter-web' ...
- STL 仿函数(函数对象)
##定义 仿函数(functor):一种具有函数性质的对象. 仿函数在C++中的新名称为函数对象(function object). 仿函数类对象像函数一样被调用,调用仿函数类对象时,实际调用的是仿函 ...
- this,static,执行程序的顺序等等留意点
self.static 和 $this 的区别为了更好地理解 self.static 和 $this 的区别,先来看一个示例. <?phpclass A { protected $name = ...