This paper presented a very interesting topic. Censorship in China has always drawn people’s attention since in a perspective of universal values censorship repress the free will of people to express themselves. This paper, focusing on the censorship in China, is sure to arouse peoples’ hot discussion and exert its impact on society. It occurs to me that western researchers are doing some 'real' research that can have great impact. They can always grasp the most important and interested topics in the world, look into these topics and yield some interesting and deep insights. I can not help but wonder why researchers in Asian countries didn’t find these topics (Well, it seems a little off the point since this topic involves complex problems concerning political and cultural factors).

Let us come back to this paper.

(Source: King et al., 2014)

My focus is on the methodological aspect. This article uses randomized experimentation, which provides a very strong support to the results and conclusion this paper made. I think, this is the most shining point of this paper, which enable it to be published in Science.

How did the authors do the experiment? As we know, an true experiment should have a treatment group, a control group, a independent variable related to treatment, dependent variable that measures the effect, random assignment, and various requirements to guarantee internal validity. The identification of experiment elements in this study is easy. Because the cause precedes the effect, we can tell that each post is the subject which the treatment works on, the treatment is the construction of the content within each post, and the reaction of the censor is the effect. In this sense, the independent variable would be the content of the post, which can be classified into four categories based on two variables: pro-government, anti-government, with collective action potential, and without collective action potential. The dependent variable is the censoring result of the post, in other words, the outcome in terms of censorship. As for random assignment, this paper has made a lot of efforts to ensure its implementation. So far as I can find, the paper did the randomization in a lot of details. For example, when submitting two posts about two different events to each account, the authors randomized (i) the choice between these two pairs, (ii) the order within each pair, and (iii) the specific collective action and policy events we wrote about in each submission. Furthermore, to fulfill the requirements of a true experiment and eliminate possible threats to its internal validity, the author takes many measures, including having the same keyword included in both the treatment and control conditions, controlling for individual writing styles, having all posts in a similar length, ensuring no identical posts to anyone found in social media, and not being obtrusive to change the social media ecosystem.

This study also employed participant observation to obtain the descriptive knowledge of how the censorship process works. in order to supplement the method of experimentation. This method is typically adopted by qualitative researchers. But in this paper, it fits in very well and provides informative materials of censorship to the researchers. Together with experimentation, it gives the authors good way to tell a more interesting story.

I think such an impressive and potentially-illegal-in-China work could not be done without help of a native Chinese. Not surprisingly, I noticed that the second author of this paper, Jennifer Pan ── a talented PhD candidate in Harvard ── is actually a Chinese. She must have got a lot of help inside mainland China, and recruited a myriad of research assistants to help with the extensive post writing and publishing.

 

Bibliography

King, G., Pan, J., & Roberts, M. E. (2014). Reverse-engineering censorship in China: Randomized experimentation and participant observation. Science, 345(6199). doi: 10.1126/science.1251722

An interesting experiment on China’s censorship的更多相关文章

  1. cf558c(bfs)

    C. Amr and Chemistry time limit per test 1 second memory limit per test 256 megabytes input standard ...

  2. Codeforces Round #312 (Div. 2) C. Amr and Chemistry 暴力

    C. Amr and Chemistry Time Limit: 20 Sec Memory Limit: 256 MB 题目连接 http://codeforces.com/contest/558/ ...

  3. 每日一“酷”之textwrap

    介绍:需要美观打印时,可以使用textwrap模块来格式化要输出的文本,这个模块允许通过编程提高类似段落自动换行或填充特性等功能. 1 创建实例数据 sample_text = ''' I’m ver ...

  4. Codeforces Round #312 (Div. 2) C.Amr and Chemistry

    Amr loves Chemistry, and specially doing experiments. He is preparing for a new interesting experime ...

  5. Codeforces 558C Amr and Chemistry 暴力 - -

    点击打开链接 Amr and Chemistry time limit per test 1 second memory limit per test 256 megabytes input stan ...

  6. CF 558 C. Amr and Chemistry 暴力+二进制

    链接:http://codeforces.com/problemset/problem/558/C C. Amr and Chemistry time limit per test 1 second ...

  7. QDU_CEF(补)

    C - Arthur and Table Arthur has bought a beautiful big table into his new flat. When he came home, A ...

  8. Amr and Chemistry

    C. Amr and Chemistry time limit per test 1 second memory limit per test 256 megabytes input standard ...

  9. codeforces 558C C. Amr and Chemistry(bfs)

    题目链接: C. Amr and Chemistry time limit per test 1 second memory limit per test 256 megabytes input st ...

随机推荐

  1. javascript学习笔记(四):事件处理函数和动态创建html标记。

    1 HTML的事件属性  全局事件属性:HTML 4 增加了使事件在浏览器中触发动作的能力,比如当用户点击元素时启动 JavaScript. a. Window 事件属性,针对 window 对象触发 ...

  2. 也来玩玩 javascript对象深拷贝,浅拷贝

    经常看到讨论c#深拷贝,浅拷贝的博客,最近js写的比较多, 所以也来玩玩js的对象拷贝. 下面是维基百科对深浅拷贝的解释: 浅拷贝 One method of copying an object is ...

  3. 多语言架构下如何正确的使用SQL视图

    产品的定位 做产品的都知道,是否支持多语言直接影响到产品的定位问题. 如果一个产品周期是一年的话,要完美支持多语言最少也得在加3个月!所需时间和页面数量.数据库表的数量和表的数据量成正比. 可以看出代 ...

  4. Maven提高篇系列之(四)——使用Profile

    这是一个Maven提高篇的系列,包含有以下文章: Maven提高篇系列之(一)——多模块 vs 继承 Maven提高篇系列之(二)——配置Plugin到某个Phase(以Selenium集成测试为例) ...

  5. VUE 表单元素双向绑定总结

    checkbox最基本用法: <input type="checkbox" v-model="inputdata" checked/> <in ...

  6. C#深入.NET平台的软件系统分层开发

    今天我们来讲讲分层开发,你从标题能不能简单的认识一下什么是分层呢? 不懂也没关系,接下来我来给你讲讲. 第一章 软件系统的分层开发 (1)其实分层模式可以这样定义:将解决方案中功能不同的模块分到不同的 ...

  7. Socket开发框架之数据传输协议

    我在前面一篇随笔<Socket开发框架之框架设计及分析>中,介绍了整个Socket开发框架的总体思路,对各个层次的基类进行了一些总结和抽象,已达到重用.简化代码的目的.本篇继续分析其中重要 ...

  8. .net又一个生成缩略图的方法,不变形

    生成缩略图是一个十分常用功能,找到了一个方法,重写部分代码,实用又好用,.net又一个生成缩略图的方法,不变形 /// <summary> /// 为图片生成缩略图 by 何问起 /// ...

  9. Nancy FormsAuthentication使用

    1.新建UserDatabase类,实现IUserMapper接口 using System; using System.Collections.Generic; using System.Linq; ...

  10. 为什么说Babel将推动JavaScript的发展

    Babel是一个转换编译器,它能将ES6转换成可以在浏览器中运行的代码.Babel由来自澳大利亚的开发者Sebastian McKenzie创建.他的目标是使Babel可以处理ES6的所有新语法,并为 ...