"The areal units (zonal objects) used in many geographical studies are arbitrary, modifiable, and subject to the whims and fancies of whoever is doing, or did, the aggregating."
                                                                                                                        ---------------------- Stan Openshaw (1983)

"Results about the effects of area-based attributes on individual behaviors or outcome can be affected by how contextual units or neighborhoods are geographically delineated and the extent to which these areal units deviate from the true geographic context."
                                                                                                                        ---------------------- Mei-Po Kwan (2012)

GDP per capita in China in 2010 made by Worldmapper

I think the two references above have given very well-summarized accounts about the Modifiable Area Unit Problem (MAUP) and Uncertain Geographic Context Problem (UGCoP). They both state the essence of the problems, i.e., the causes where the problems arise. Interesting and simply put as they are, however, it is not easy to paraphrase them in a unsophisticated and easy-to-understand way. As such, this article aims to explain the two problems using words that don’t duplicate in the original articles by the authors.

Let’s look at the UGCoP first.
The essence of UGCoP is that the authenticity of research could be compromised due to the inaccurate description of the true geographic context by using geographic area/space. Put it in another way, it is the gap between the true geographic context and the geographical area/space we used to depict the context that has caused the problem. True geographic context here refers to the precise spatial configuration or areas that exert contextual influences on the individuals being studied. In the original article by Prof. Kwan, UGCoP is said to consist of two dimensions, which are spatial uncertainty and temporal uncertainty. Spatial uncertainty, from her point of view, is evidenced by several aspects in terms of the complexity of geographical context: multiple contexts of human activities, discrete geographical space which one context may cover, indefinable contexts by using geographical space (aspatial contexts), inaccurate geographical representation to the true geographical context, and lastly the variability of the contexts per se.
As for temporal uncertainty, however, it is not appropriate to mention the two uncertainties in the same breath, in my opinion. Spatial uncertainty is the major cause and component of UGCoP, while temporal uncertainty only plays a minor and subsidiary role component in UGCoP. Its function is only to make the problem of UGCoP more complicated. Specifically, the extensive temporal variability of human activities and contexts we study, as well as the time lag effect of contextual influence and human migration, add more complexities into spatial uncertainty.

MAUP is related to UGCoP, but it tells a different story. Let me explain by explicating their commonalities and differences.
Bothe MAUP and UGCoP share some common features. First, they both deal with the research result accuracy problem; Second they are both caused by ambiguous and untrue geographical delineation.
As for the differences, firstly, if you look into the nuance of the causes of the two problems, you will find the causes are actually different. MAUP is caused by arbitrary and unjustified zoning schemes, while UGCoP is due to the incomplete information transfer and inability of inter-describing between geographical space and contextual influences. Secondly, MAUP is almost incurable, while UGCoP can be remedied to some extent.

References
Openshaw, S. (1983). The modifiable areal unit problem (Vol. 38): Geo Books Norwich.
Kwan, M.-P. (2012). The uncertain geographic context problem. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 102(5), 958-968.

Understanding the Uncertain Geographic Context Problem的更多相关文章

  1. 区分DDD中的Domain, Subdomain, Bounded Context, Problem/Solution Space

    区分DDD中的Domain, Subdomain, Bounded Context, Problem/Solution Space 译自: Domain, Subdomain, Bounded Con ...

  2. SICP 阅读笔记(二)

    Chapter 1: Building Abstractions with Procedures 2015-09-29 016 Preface of this chapter QUOTE: The a ...

  3. JAVA工程师技能要求

    近期做了个JAVA工程师分类, JAVA工程师可能是市场上最多类的程序员:   初级JAVA工程师的基本要求 Good basic programming skills 良好基本编程技能 Founda ...

  4. GIS和视频监控的集成

    本文讨论了使用增强现实(AR)技术的三维(3D)地理信息系统(GIS)和视频监视系统的集成.进行这种集成的动机是要克服常规视频监视系统面临的问题.关于哪个摄像机当前监视此类系统中哪个区域的明确信息:因 ...

  5. atitit.软件与sql设计模式原理与本质 大总结attialx总结v6 qc26.docx

    atitit.软件与sql设计模式原理与本质 大总结attialx总结v6 qc26.docx 1.1. 版本历史2 2. 设计模式是什么2 2.1. 模式就是在一种场合下对某个问题的一个解决方案.& ...

  6. Normalization

    In creating a database, normalization is the process of organizing it into tables in such a way that ...

  7. Common Pitfalls In Machine Learning Projects

    Common Pitfalls In Machine Learning Projects In a recent presentation, Ben Hamner described the comm ...

  8. Leetcode: Max Sum of Rectangle No Larger Than K

    Given a non-empty 2D matrix matrix and an integer k, find the max sum of a rectangle in the matrix s ...

  9. Java fundamentals of basic IO

    IO is a problem difficult to handle in various of systems because it  always becomes a bottleneck in ...

随机推荐

  1. 给 Web 前端开发人员推荐20款 CSS 编辑器

    CSS 和 HTML,JavaScript 是网页的基础,作为前端开发人员,对这三者都要很熟悉.特别是未来流行全栈开发的时代,每项技术都是你知识结构中必要的一个节点. 在开发中,选择好工具是非常重要的 ...

  2. [Python] urllib2.HTTPError: HTTP Error 403: Forbidden

    搬运自http://www.2cto.com/kf/201309/242273.html,感谢原作. 之所以出现上面的异常,是因为如果用 urllib.request.urlopen 方式打开一个UR ...

  3. Javascript: 从prototype漫谈到继承(2)

    本文同时也发表在我另一篇独立博客 <Javascript: 从prototype漫谈到继承(2)>(管理员请注意!这两个都是我自己的原创博客!不要踢出首页!不是转载!已经误会三次了!) 上 ...

  4. 重读 code complete 说说代码质量

    重读code complete 说说代码质量 2014年的第一篇文章本来计划写些过去一年的总结和新年展望,但是因为还有一些事情要过一阵才能完成,所以姑且不谈这个,说说最近重读code complete ...

  5. Elasticsearch聚合 之 Ip Range IP地址范围聚合

    相对于range和date range,这个聚合就是能够表示IP的范围. 普通IP模式 DSL命令: { "aggs":{ "ip_ranges":{ &quo ...

  6. iOS平台快速发布HT for Web拓扑图应用

    iOS平台一直是封闭的生态圈,iOS开发者要缴纳年费加入开发者计划才可进行iOS平台的APP开发测试,所开发的APP需要上传到App Store经过苹果审核以后才可对外发布.如果要开发企业内部应用,则 ...

  7. Java魔法堂:类加载器入了个门

    一.前言 <Java魔法堂:类加载机制入了个门>中提及整个类加载流程中只有加载阶段作为码农的我们可以入手干预,其余均由JVM处理.本文将记录加载阶段的核心组件——类加载器的相关信息,以便日 ...

  8. 博客已经转移到http://geekori.cn,本博客不再更新

    已经建立了独立博客:极客起源(http://geekori.cn),并将大部分博文已经转移到新的博客,本博客不再更新.

  9. HTML知识点01

    HTML基础知识回顾 1:ie是浏览器的一种,一般的浏览器只是用到了IE的内盒,知识将IE做了个外包. 2:书写HTML时要按照XML标准类书写.有开始就有结束. 3:HTML种属性单双引号都可以,也 ...

  10. C# winform OpenFileDialog MessageBox

    1.弹出窗体选择本地文件-OpenFileDialog OpenFileDialog openFileDialog = new OpenFileDialog(); openFileDialog.Tit ...