The HTML specifications technically define the difference between "GET" and "POST" so that former means that form data is to be encoded (by a browser) into a URL while the latter means that the form data is to appear within a message body. But the specifications also give the usage recommendation that the "GET" method should be used when the form processing is "idempotent", and in those cases only. As a simplification, we might say that "GET" is basically for just getting (retrieving) data whereas "POST" may involve anything, like storing or updating data, or ordering a product, or sending E-mail.

The HTML 2.0 specification says, in section Form Submission (and the HTML 4.0 specificationrepeats this with minor stylistic changes):

If the processing of a form is idempotent (i.e. it has no lasting observable effect on the state of the world), then the form method should be GET. Many database searches have no visible side-effects and make ideal applications of query forms.

- -

If the service associated with the processing of a form has side effects (for example, modification of a database or subscription to a service), the method should be POST.

In the HTTP specifications (specifically RFC 2616) the word idempotent is defined as follows:

Methods can also have the property of "idempotence" in that (aside from error or expiration issues) the side-effects of N > 0 identical requests is the same as for a single request.

The word idempotent, as used in this context in the specifications, is (pseudo)mathematical jargon (see definition of "idempotent" in FOLDOC) and should not be taken too seriously or literally here. The phrase "no lasting observable effect on the state of the world" isn't of course very exact either, and isn't really the same thing. Idempotent processing, as defined above, does not exclude fundamental changes, only that processing the same data twice has the same effect as processing it once. But here, in fact, idempotent processing means that a form submission causesno changes anywhere except on the user's screen (or, more generally speaking, in the user agent's state). Thus, it is basically for retrieving data. If such a form is resubmitted, it might get different data (if the data had been changed meanwhile), but the submission would not cause any update of data or other events. The concept of changes should not be taken too pedantically; for instance, it can hardly be regarded as a change that a form submission is logged into the server's log file. On the other hand, sending E-mail should normally be regarded as "an effect on the state of the world".

The HTTP specifications aren't crystal clear on this, and section Safe Methods in the HTTP/1.1 specification describes the principles in yet another way. It opens a different perspective by saying that users "cannot be held accountable" for side effects, which presumably means any effect than mere retrieval:

In particular, the convention has been established that the GET and HEAD methods SHOULD NOT have the significance of taking an action other than retrieval. These methods ought to be considered "safe". This allows user agents to represent other methods, such as POST, PUT and DELETE, in a special way, so that the user is made aware of the fact that a possibly unsafe action is being requested.

Naturally, it is not possible to ensure that the server does not generate side-effects as a result of performing a GET request; in fact, some dynamic resources consider that a feature. The important distinction here is that the user did not request the side-effects, so therefore cannot be held accountable for them.

The concept and its background is explained in section Allowing input in Tim Berners-Lee's Style Guide for online hypertext. It refers, for more information, to User agent watch points, which emphatically says that GET should be used if and only if there are no side effects. But this line of thought, however logical, is not always practical at present, as we shall see.

The fundamental differences between "GET" and "POST"的更多相关文章

  1. Build an ETL Pipeline With Kafka Connect via JDBC Connectors

    This article is an in-depth tutorial for using Kafka to move data from PostgreSQL to Hadoop HDFS via ...

  2. Transistor 晶体管 场效应 双极型 达林顿 CMOS PMOS BJT FET

    Transistor Tutorial Summary Transistor Tutorial Summary Bipolar Junction Transistor Tutorial We can ...

  3. git和svn的区别001

    Git和SVN之间的五个基本区别 中文原文地址:http://blog.jobbole.com/31444/ 友情链接git和svn链接2:http://blog.csdn.net/sunboy_20 ...

  4. Embedded之Introduction

    1 Embedded system An embedded system is a combination of computer hardware and software, and perhaps ...

  5. git 和 svn的区别(转)

    英文原文:5 Fundamental differences between GIT & SVN,编译:外刊IT评论 如果你在读这篇文章,说明你跟大多数开发者一样对GIT感兴趣,如果你还没有机 ...

  6. System Address Map Initialization in x86/x64 Architecture Part 2: PCI Express-Based Systems

      原文  http://resources.infosecinstitute.com/system-address-map-initialization-x86x64-architecture-pa ...

  7. Html代码Font-Size中px与pt的区别

    一个是设备坐标,一个是逻辑坐标,两者是不同的. px是个相对单位,一般像素的参考值为:在一个像素密度是90 pdi的显示器上,正常人从距离显示器28英寸处看一个像素的视角应该不小于0.0227度. 1 ...

  8. Big Data Analytics for Security(Big Data Analytics for Security Intelligence)

    http://www.infoq.com/articles/bigdata-analytics-for-security This article first appeared in the IEEE ...

  9. 为什么说 Git 比 SVN 更好

    为什么说 Git 比 SVN 更好 在版本控制系统的选型上,是选择Git还是SVN? 对于开源项目来说这不算问题.使用Git极大地提高了开发效率.扩大了开源项目的参与度. 增强了版本控制系统的安全性, ...

随机推荐

  1. hdu5072

    补集转化,求不符合条件的三元组数目 但是怎么统计呢,这里我没想到 [如果三个数a, b, c不符合条件,那么一定有一对是互质的,有一对是不互质的.不妨令a, b互质,b, c不互质.于是我们可以枚举b ...

  2. Windows和Ubuntu平台Android +JAVA 环境搭建

    NOTE 测试的时候,尤其是移动端的测试,需要搭建JAVA和Andriod环境: appium和macaca都需要这两个环境: Q&A Macaca doctor 发现没有platforms这 ...

  3. python 文件路径操作方法(转)

    Python编程语言在实际使用中可以帮助我们轻松的实现一些特殊的功能需求.在这里我们将会为大家详细介绍一下有关Python文件路径的相关操作技巧,从而方便我们在实际开发中获得一些帮助. Python文 ...

  4. strcmp()函数-比较字符串的大小、字符串排序

    1.比较字符串的大小: 用法:strcmp(字符串1,字符串2),若字符串1>字符串2 则返回1,字符串1<字符串2 则返回 -1,相等返回0. 比较两个字符串的算法是:逐个比较两个串中对 ...

  5. DFS之奇偶剪枝

    问题描述: 给定一个 N * M的迷宫+起点+终点 ,迷宫中有一些障碍无法穿过,问能否不重复也不停留地在刚好一共走 t 步出迷宫. 先上结论: 在理想情况下,s到e需要的最小步数为m=|ex-sx|+ ...

  6. Python练习——同时安装python2 与 python 3如何选择不同解释器运行脚本

    如果同时安装了python 2 和python 3 那么我们需要在运行时指定解释器 如下: 其中py -2 ex1.py指定了解释器的版本,以及打开的文件 如果使用 py-3 ex1.py则使用了py ...

  7. 购物平台webApp+服务后台开发

    服务器后台参考:Cloud BaaS 主站地址:http://cloudbaas.sinaapp.com/ 演示地址:http://jeebaas.sinaapp.com/ Mobile UI 框架: ...

  8. [BZOJ 3152] 组合子逻辑

    Link: BZOJ 3152 传送门 Solution: 喜闻乐见,gyz出的语文题,题意要看半小时 题意:使用最少的括号将序列分割,对于每个括号中的序列,设最左边的数为$num$,序列中元素个数为 ...

  9. CodeForces - 981D Bookshelves

    Discription Mr Keks is a typical white-collar in Byteland. He has a bookshelf in his office with som ...

  10. 【set】bzoj3715 [PA2014]Lustra

    对每种属性开一个set,只要某个厂家符合该属性的最值,就加进set,最后判断是否有某个厂家在4个set里都存在即可. #include<cstdio> #include<set> ...