Thoughts on an Article from Science 'A network framework of cultural history'
Apparently, this is an excellent interdisciplinary study. This paper drawn on a simple but large database that contains notable individuals in Europe and North America over two thousand years, analyzed their migration activities by utilizing tools and metrics from the domain of computer science, demography, linguistic studies, etc., and finally obtained many interesting insights and findings.
Birth and death data of notable individuals reveal interactions between culturally relevant locations over two millennia by Schich et al.(2014)
The structure of this paper is sound, clear and approachable, as many other articles published in Science magazine always are. In the first paragraph, this paper presents the research problem clearly. With the emphasis on the many implications of quantifying historical developments as the beginning, It says, 'there is inherent tension between qualitative analyze of individual accounts and quantitative approaches...'. Then, the authors indicate the data source of this paper and describe them in detail. The paragraphs that followed are the major parts of this paper in which the authors condense their findings into three figures. All the stories and explications revolve around the three figures. The first figure, as its name suggests, focuses on the interactions between cultural locations by connecting the locations with birth and death of notable individuals. This figure has a impact on me because it shows a lot of implications for urban researches, place making and promotion, which I would explain later. The second figure reveals global patterns and local instabilities in human mobility dynamics. As the authors says in the paper, several insights found in this study are in line with some empirical laws such as Heaps' law, Zip's law and Ravenstein's laws of migration. As for figure 3, it did a fantastic visualization job which offers a meta-narrative of cultural history. In the end of this paper, the authors utilized the Google Ngram English data set and conducted a match between the historical cultural events and the death rate patterns.
The methodology of this paper is worth noting. As the author says in the first paragraph, this paper adopted a mixed method of quantitative and qualitative tools. The authors use the quantitative methods to identify the statistical regularities, which are presented in figure 1 and figure 2 in this paper, and then use qualitative approaches to delineate the meta-narrative of cultural history in figure 3. In addition to this mixed and complementary methods, this paper employed a lot of metrics from other domain of disciplines. For example, PageRank, a metric that measures centrality of a network in computational technology, is used to denote the relative importance of cultural locations. This shows the power of inter-disciplinary studies.
This paper has intrigued me. I can't help think that, why not do a similar study in China, during a specific period, on a specific group of people? This idea agrees with the authors' final statement without prior consultation, in which the authors says, "Our approach allows for cross-fertilization of domain knowledge into other domains, periods, and geographic areas." Therefore, I plan to propose the following study:
"Chinese Cities and Chinese Elites' Migration in Chinese History"
Thousands of Chinese Elites in ancient China have shaped the Chinese history, as well as Chinese cities...
[Anyone who is interested please contact me at jazzyl@qq.com]
Thoughts on an Article from Science 'A network framework of cultural history'的更多相关文章
- Case1-basic network framework/Related organization‘s name
常见的计算机网络物理拓扑结构: 1.星型网 2.树型网 3.分布式网络 4.总线型网 5.环型网 6.复合型网络 计算机网络相关的标准化组织: 国际标准化组织(ISO):International O ...
- Neural Network Toolbox使用笔记1:数据拟合
http://blog.csdn.net/ljp1919/article/details/42556261 Neural Network Toolbox为各种复杂的非线性系统的建模提供多种函数和应用程 ...
- Deep Learning 学习随记(五)Deep network 深度网络
这一个多周忙别的事去了,忙完了,接着看讲义~ 这章讲的是深度网络(Deep Network).前面讲了自学习网络,通过稀疏自编码和一个logistic回归或者softmax回归连接,显然是3层的.而这 ...
- 智能合约遇到的小错误 network up to date解决办法
https://blog.csdn.net/qindong564950620/article/details/68933678 说 network up to date .这个错误我刚开始不知道怎么解 ...
- Network Embedding
网络表示 网络表示学习(DeepWalk,LINE,node2vec,SDNE) https://blog.csdn.net/u013527419/article/details/76017528 网 ...
- (zhuan) Recurrent Neural Network
Recurrent Neural Network 2016年07月01日 Deep learning Deep learning 字数:24235 this blog from: http:/ ...
- MatterTrack Route Of Network Traffic :: Matter
Python 1.1 基础 while语句 字符串边缘填充 列出文件夹中的指定文件类型 All Combinations For A List Of Objects Apply Operations ...
- Chinese culture
文房四宝 笔墨纸砚是中国古代文人书房中必备的宝贝,被称为“文房四宝”.用笔墨书写绘画在 中国可追溯到五千年前.秦(前221---前206)时已用不同硬度的毛和竹管制笔:汉代(前206—公元220) ...
- Beginners Guide To Learn Dimension Reduction Techniques
Beginners Guide To Learn Dimension Reduction Techniques Introduction Brevity is the soul of wit This ...
随机推荐
- VS2012连接到OSC@Git
osc终于全面开放git库了,这是我一直期待的事,也是促使我从CSDN转回OSC社区的重要原因之一.而这次我来教大家如何用osc@git来进行简单的版本控制.对于git,我自身也是近几周才开始学习,有 ...
- 基于MVC4+EasyUI的Web开发框架经验总结(15)--在MVC项目中使用RDLC报表
RDLC是一个不错的报表,有着比较不错的设计模式和展现效果,在我的Winform开发里面,使用RDLC也是一个比较方便操作,如可以参考文章<DevExpress的XtraReport和微软RDL ...
- 介绍开源的.net通信框架NetworkComms框架 源码分析(五)ReservedPacketType
原文网址: http://www.cnblogs.com/csdev Networkcomms 是一款C# 语言编写的TCP/UDP通信框架 作者是英国人 以前是收费的 目前作者已经开源 许可是 ...
- all requires API level 3 (current min is 1)问题的解决
几次出现了all requires API level 3 (current min is 1)的错误,后来发现解决的方法是右键单击项目文件夹,选择Android Tools->Clear Li ...
- 口袋微博android源码服务端和客户端
刚刚在源码天堂看到了一个不错的安卓SNS应用源码,而且也比较完整的,它基本具备了新浪微博的所有功能,包括查看最新的微博.微博评论.好友资料.回复评论以及发私信等,除此之外,还提供了许多独有的特色功能: ...
- Time series database
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_series_database https://influxdb.com/docs/v0.9/introduction/getti ...
- idea配置maven并添加镜像配置
1.打开maven存放文件夹找到 conf ->settings.xml 找到<mirrors>节点把下面内容写入节点内 配置为阿里云的镜像 <mirror> <i ...
- Mybatis批量添加对象List
1.对应的xml文件: <!--批量添加--><insert id="insertStandardItemInfo" parameterType="ha ...
- Scalaz(5)- typeclass:my typeclass scalaz style-demo
我们在上一篇讨论中介绍了一些基本的由scalaz提供的typeclass.这些基本typeclass主要的作用是通过操作符来保证类型安全,也就是在前期编译时就由compiler来发现错误.在这篇讨论中 ...
- 剖析信用卡 DCC 交易
摘要: 所谓DCC交易(Dynamic Currency Conversion,直译:动态货币转换 ),或者叫CPC交易(Cardholder Preferred Currency,直译:持卡人选定货 ...